South Carolina spent just under $1.5 million on three days in New York City in September.1 About six weeks later the state reported 16.2 million impressions.2 The published reports don’t say what the goal was.
That raises two separate issues, and they get different answers.
The first is whether government should be in the marketing business. There’s a case for it. Tourism is a major industry here, New York is our largest visitor market outside the Southeast, and no single hotel can advertise a whole state. There’s a case against it too. The businesses that gain from visitors can buy their own ads, a tax dollar spent on a billboard is a dollar that could have stayed with the person who earned it, and marketing isn’t a core function of government. I understand both arguments. That decision belongs to the General Assembly, and the General Assembly has made it.
The second issue is whether we measure success. This one isn’t a matter of opinion.
The money bought seven digital billboards in Times Square and a South Carolina showcase in Grand Central Terminal. Along with the impressions, the state tourism department reported more than 20,000 consumer interactions and website traffic up 84 percent. The published reports don’t say 84 percent of what, and it matters, because 84 percent more than 10 visitors a day is nothing like 84 percent more than 10,000. They don’t say what the department expected to get, either. So we don’t know whether these results beat the goal, fell short of it, or whether there was a goal at all.
When you sell your house, you ask the agent two things before you sign: what price she expects and how long it should take. If she came back after the open house and told you 200 people walked through, that might be good news. But you didn’t hire her for foot traffic. You hired her to sell the house. With no price and no date written down, you couldn’t tell a good month from a bad one.
The numbers from New York are foot traffic. An impression is counted each time an ad or a post is shown, so one person who walks past the same billboard five times counts five times. If the goal was 10 million impressions, 16.2 million is a win. If the goal was 30 million, it’s a miss. The number that matters most is how many more people came to South Carolina. That one takes time. The department calls its results preliminary.
At the company I built, nobody spent $1.5 million on marketing and then reported whatever numbers came in. You said up front what you expected. Then you measured against it and reported to the board.
It can be done in government. North Carolina’s tourism office puts its return in print every year. For 2024 it claimed more than 610,000 trips, $144 in visitor spending for every advertising dollar, and $13 in state and local taxes for every dollar spent.3 South Carolina used to report the same kind of number. In 2000 the tourism department said its advertising returned $31 for every $1.4 Its latest annual report says how many households remembered the ads and how many trips followed, but it gives no dollar return.5
I’m skeptical of numbers like those. They’re estimates from a survey, done by a firm the agency pays, and I don’t think it’s as simple as every dollar bringing back $13. In Florida, the legislature’s own economists do the count every three years. In normal years they found the state got back about $2 to $3 for every dollar it spent. For the pandemic years they found 58 cents, and they published that too.6 At least Florida’s number is out where people can argue with it. You can’t argue with a number nobody prints.
The Department of Commerce has the same problem. It puts public money into incentives, the grants and tax credits for companies that promise jobs, for the same reason the tourism department buys ads: to bring more money back. In 2020 the legislature’s auditors recommended that Commerce go back and measure what its incentives returned. In 2024 the auditors reported Commerce’s answer. It “has not found a credible way.”7
When an agency spends public money and can’t show what it bought, people start to wonder whether the rest of state government spends the same way. That doubt lands on every agency, including the ones that count every dollar.
I don’t know whether the New York money was well spent. Nobody outside the department can tell from what has been published. Some of this spending will prove out and some will not, and that is to be expected. But when the state spends money to make money, it should set a goal before the money goes out and count what came back. If an agency can’t measure what came back, or doesn’t, the state shouldn’t be spending the money. Whatever the General Assembly decides to fund, that’s a fair thing to ask. You’d ask the same of $1,500 of your own. This was nearly $1.5 million.
Next week: You Can’t Drain a $6 Billion Bathtub with a $200 Million Teacup. The law passed this spring to end the income tax cuts it by about $200 million in a good year, and in a good year the tax grows by about $300 million.
Last week: We are just getting started.
Post and Courier, “SC meets Manhattan in state tourism pop-up at NYC’s Grand Central and Times Square,” September 25, 2026: just under $1.5 million, from additional marketing money the General Assembly gave the department this year.
Post and Courier, “South Carolina spent $1.5M on a New York City takeover. Here’s how it paid off,” November 7, 2026, and WSPA, “South Carolina spends $1.5 million on tourism advertising campaign in NYC.” Preliminary results released by state tourism officials. Neither report gives a goal set before the event, the starting figure for website traffic, or a definition of a consumer interaction.
Visit North Carolina 2024 Annual Report: more than 610,000 trips, $815 million in ad-influenced visitor spending, and $144 in visitor spending per dollar of media, measured by SMARInsights. Tax return of $13 per $1: Visit NC 101 partner deck, February 2026, citing the same study.
S.C. Department of Parks, Recreation and Tourism, Annual Accountability Report FY 1999/2000, S.C. State Library Digital Collections.
SCPRT FY 2024-25 Annual Accountability Report, p. 18: 42 percent ad awareness and 816,000 trips to counties other than Horry, Charleston and Beaufort.
Florida Legislature, Office of Economic and Demographic Research, “Return on Investment for VISIT FLORIDA,” March 2024: 0.58 for FY 2019-20 through 2021-22; the three earlier reviews found 3.27, 2.15 and 3.21. Florida’s figure counts state revenue only; North Carolina’s $13 includes local taxes.
Legislative Audit Council, follow-up review of the Department of Commerce, August 2024, p.2, Recommendation 10 of the June 2020 audit: that Commerce conduct a “look back” analysis of the fiscal impact of projects approved for grants and job development credits. Status: not implemented.




What a novel idea! Measure results based on expectations. Great article. Can’t wait to see the financial information published for all to see.
You might also need to post a primer of how to read the published data.
Congratulations on your win and good luck. I enjoy your investgation on where our money has been spent.